Skip to main content

Table 1 Pre- and post-intervention essential birth practice compliance rate

From: Implementing the World Health Organization safe childbirth checklist in a district Hospital in Rwanda: a pre- and post-intervention study

EBP

pre-intervention

post-intervention

P-value

Pause point 1. “On admission”

Observations (n)

106

95

 1. Appropriate referral

100 (100%)

100 (100%)

1.000

 2. Maternal temperature **

75 (70.8%)

51 (53.7%)

0.014**

 3. Maternal blood pressure

90 (84.9%)

81 (85.3%)

1.000

 4. Partograph started

59 (55.7%)

45 (47.4%)

0.26

 5. Birth companion **

1 (0.9%)

7 (7.4%)

0.028**

Average

65 (61%)

56.8 (60%)

0.848

Pause point 2. “Before pushing and within 1 min after delivery”

Observations (n)

92

98

 

 6. Water used to clean hands

22 (22.4%)

18 (18.2%)

0.483

 7. Soap used to clean hands

18 (18.4%)

17 (17.2%)

0.854

 8. Alcohol rub used

2 (2%)

3 (3%)

1.000

 9. Clean towel **

63 (64.3%)

84 (85.7%)

0.001**

 10. Clean gloves used

100(100%)

100(100%)

1.000

 11. Clean scissors/ blade

88 (89.8%)

84 (84.8%)

0.392

 12. Clean cord ligature/tie **

58 (59.2%)

89 (90.8%)

< 0.001**

 13. Aspiration bulb or Mucus extractor

66 (67.3%)

70 (70.7%)

0.646

 14. Clean pads for mother **

43 (43.9%)

61 (61.6%)

0.015**

 15. Oxytocin

76 (77.6%)

84 (84.8%)

0.206

 16. Birth companion present **

0 (0%)

10 (10.2%)

0.002**

Average

48.7 (53%)

56.4 (58%)

0.591

Pause point 3. “Within 1 h after delivery”

Observation (n)

92

98

 

 17. Newborn weight taken**

76 (77.6%)

94 (94.9%)

< 0.001**

 18. Newborn temperature

5 (5.1%)

4 (4.1%)

1.000

 19. Neonatal bag and mask prepared

69 (70.4%)

69 (69.7%)

1.000

 20. Baby placed skin-to-skin**

48 (49.0%)

89 (89.9%)

< 0.001**

 21. baby still skin-to-skin at 1 h

2 (2.0%)

6 (6.1%)

0.279

 22. Breastfeeding initiated**

32 (32.7%)

47 (47.5%)

0.042**

Average

38.7 (42%)

51.5 (53%)

0.161

Pause point 4. “Before discharge”

Observation (n)

101

98

 

 23. Maternal blood pressure obtained**

14 (13.9%)

58 (58.6%)

< 0.001**

 24. Mother’s temperature **

3 (3.0%)

54 (54.5%)

< 0.001**

 25. Baby’s temperature

1 (1.0%)

5 (5.1%)

0.115

 26. Baby’s respiratory rate

1 (1.0%)

5 (5.1%)

0.115

 27. Baby’s feeding

89 (88.1%)

84 (84.8%)

0.54

 28. Family planning options discussed

94 (93.1%)

88 (88.9%)

0.333

 29. Danger signs explained **

1 (1.0%)

66 (66.7%)

< 0.001**

Average **

29 (29%)

51.4 (52%)

0.001**

Overall compliance

   

Observation (n)

391

389

 

Overall average **

46%

56%

0.005**

  1. **Statistically significant at P = 0.05